Are bigger dogs smarter than smaller dogs? It is an interesting question, especially when you compare a Great Dane with a Chihuahua or a German Shepherd with a Toy Poodle. Size is easy to notice, but intelligence is more complicated than it might seem.
Research suggests that brain size is associated with certain cognitive abilities in dogs, including short-term memory and self-control. However, these findings do not mean that every large dog is smarter than every small dog. To understand the relationship, it helps to look at what scientists actually measured and what their findings can tell us about our canine companions.
What Does Research Say About Dog Size and Intelligence?
A study led by researchers at the University of Arizona, published in the journal Animal Cognition in 2019, examined cognitive data from more than 7,000 purebred dogs representing 74 breeds. The researchers estimated brain size using breed information and investigated whether it was associated with differences in several cognitive tasks.
The results showed that breeds with larger estimated brain sizes performed better on two particular measures: short-term memory and self-control. These abilities are part of what scientists call executive function, which helps animals manage information and regulate their behavior.
However, the relationship between estimated brain size and performance differed across cognitive tasks. The researchers did not establish that larger dogs are universally more intelligent or that body size alone determines how well an individual dog learns.
You can read more about the research in the University of Arizona's explanation of the study.
How Does Brain Size Relate to Canine Intelligence?
The brain plays an essential role in memory, learning, problem-solving and behavior. It is therefore reasonable to investigate whether differences in brain size are associated with differences in cognitive performance.
But brain size is only one part of a much larger picture. A bigger brain does not automatically mean an animal will perform better at every mental task. Researchers must consider the particular ability being tested, how the test is designed and the differences between the animals being studied.
It is also important to distinguish between a dog's body size and its brain size. The 2019 study focused on estimated absolute brain weight and breed differences in cognition. It did not establish a simple rule that can be used to rank every dog from smartest to least intelligent based on weight or height.
Short-Term Memory: One Area Where Larger-Brained Breeds Performed Better
Short-term memory allows a dog to retain information for a brief period. It can help a dog remember where a treat was hidden, keep track of something it has just seen or respond appropriately to a recently given cue.
In the study, researchers examined data from memory tasks in which dogs had to remember the location of a hidden treat after a delay. On average, breeds with larger estimated brains performed better on this measure.
This finding is interesting, but it should not be used to assume that a small dog has a poor memory. Individual dogs differ, and success in a particular test does not capture every aspect of their ability to learn and remember.
Self-Control and the Ability to Wait
Self-control is another cognitive ability associated with executive function. In everyday life, it can involve waiting for permission before taking food, resisting an immediate distraction or pausing before responding to an exciting situation.
The researchers found that larger-brained breeds also performed better on a measure of self-control. The study included tasks in which dogs had to resist taking a treat immediately under different conditions.
Still, self-control is influenced by more than brain size. A dog's training history, motivation, surroundings and level of excitement can affect its behavior. A dog that grabs a treat quickly is not necessarily less intelligent; it may simply be responding to the situation differently.
Does a Bigger Dog Have Better Social Intelligence?
Dogs are skilled at interacting with people, learning routines and responding to human signals. Some recognize familiar words, follow gestures or learn how their owners communicate with them.
These abilities are often discussed as social cognition. They are not identical to short-term memory or self-control, and a dog's performance in one area does not necessarily predict its performance in another.
The 2019 research found that the relationship between brain size and cognitive performance varied depending on the ability being examined. It therefore would be misleading to use the findings to claim that large dogs are better at every kind of social interaction—or that small dogs are naturally better at understanding people.
A dog's experiences, temperament, opportunities to learn and relationship with its owner all matter when considering how it responds to people and other animals.
Why Small Dogs Can Be Clever, Capable Learners
Anyone who has lived with a small dog knows that a compact body does not prevent a dog from learning routines, solving everyday problems or communicating its needs. Small dogs can learn cues, participate in training and enjoy activities that challenge their minds.
Different dogs may also excel at different tasks. One might be quick to learn a new trick, another might be especially responsive to its owner's gestures, and another might be highly skilled at scent-based games.
These differences are part of why canine intelligence is difficult to summarize with a single ranking. A study that measures short-term memory cannot tell us everything about a dog's ability to learn commands, cooperate with people or navigate its environment.
If you are interested in dogs known for their learning abilities, explore our guide to 10 of the smartest dog breeds. Breed rankings can be useful starting points, but they should not replace an understanding of each dog's individual personality and needs.
What Influences a Dog's Ability to Learn?
Size is only one characteristic researchers can investigate. A dog's everyday learning and behavior are shaped by several factors, including:
- Genetics and breed history: Dogs were bred for different purposes, and inherited traits can influence behavior and the tasks they tend to perform well.
- Training and experience: Dogs need opportunities to learn. Consistent, reward-based training can help them understand what is expected.
- Motivation: Food, toys, praise and opportunities to explore can affect how willing a dog is to engage with a task.
- Environment: Distractions, unfamiliar surroundings and stress can affect a dog's ability to concentrate.
- Age and health: Development, discomfort and changes in health can influence attention, memory and behavior.
These factors help explain why two dogs of similar size—or even from the same breed—may respond differently to the same training exercise.
How to Encourage Your Dog's Mental Skills
You do not need a large dog or a particular breed to enjoy activities that encourage learning. Simple, positive experiences can give dogs opportunities to use their senses, practice familiar skills and explore new challenges.
- Practice short training sessions: Teach one cue at a time and reward the behavior you want to encourage.
- Use food puzzles: Age-appropriate puzzle toys and supervised treat-finding games can encourage dogs to explore and solve simple problems.
- Play scent games: Let your dog search for a favorite toy or a small treat hidden in an easy-to-find location.
- Keep challenges manageable: Start with simple tasks and increase difficulty gradually so your dog can learn without becoming frustrated.
- Allow time for rest: Keep activities enjoyable and give your dog breaks when it loses interest or appears tired.
Use rewards your dog enjoys, keep sessions positive and adjust activities to its age, mobility and individual abilities. The aim is to provide enrichment and strengthen your relationship, not to prove that one dog is smarter than another.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are bigger dogs smarter than smaller dogs?
Not necessarily. Research involving more than 7,000 dogs from 74 breeds found that larger-brained breeds performed better on certain short-term memory and self-control tasks. The results do not mean that every large dog is smarter than every small dog or that size determines all aspects of intelligence.
Does a bigger brain mean a dog is more intelligent?
Not in every situation. Brain size has been associated with some cognitive abilities, but the relationship varies by task. Intelligence includes different skills, so brain size alone cannot provide a complete measure of an individual dog's abilities.
Can small dogs learn commands and solve problems?
Yes. Small dogs can learn cues, develop routines and take part in problem-solving activities. Their learning depends on many factors, including individual temperament, experience, motivation and training—not simply their size.
Which dog breeds are considered the smartest?
Some breeds are known for learning commands quickly or working closely with people, but there is no single ranking that captures every type of canine intelligence. Our guide to smart dog breeds offers a starting point for exploring the subject.
How can I help my dog develop its learning skills?
Use short, reward-based training sessions, introduce suitable puzzle toys, play simple scent games and provide regular opportunities to explore. Choose activities that match your dog's age, health and ability, and keep learning enjoyable.
Final Thoughts: Intelligence Is More Than Size
Research has found a relationship between estimated brain size and certain cognitive abilities in dogs, particularly short-term memory and self-control. That is a meaningful finding, but it is not proof that bigger dogs are smarter in every respect.
Dogs have different strengths, and the results of one cognitive test cannot describe everything an individual animal can do. Whether you share your home with a Great Dane, a Chihuahua or a dog somewhere in between, giving your companion opportunities to learn, explore and interact with you is far more useful than judging its intelligence by its size.
Related articles:
Research source: Horschler, D. J., et al. (2019). Absolute brain size predicts dog breed differences in executive function. Animal Cognition, 22, 187–198. Read the study on PubMed.